Loading the studies…
"Yeshua didn't qualify as the Messiah": rabbinic Judaism's objections, and what Scripture says
Rabbinic Judaism gives serious reasons for rejecting Yeshua as the Messiah. Here they are, stated fairly, with the answers Scripture gives.
If you share Yeshua with a Jewish friend, or with someone who has looked into rabbinic Judaism, you will hear these objections. They deserve a fair hearing. Many who hold them sincerely love God's word, as Paul once did Romans 10:2. Our disagreement is with the authority of rabbinic tradition, not with the Jewish people.
The objections, in their own words
The best-known statement comes from Maimonides (Rabbi Moses ben Maimon, AD 1138–1204), in his law code, the Mishneh Torah. He wrote that the Messiah will be a king from David's line who studies the Torah and keeps the commandments. If he rebuilds the temple in its place and gathers the scattered of Israel, he is certainly the Messiah. "If he did not succeed to this degree or was killed, he surely is not the redeemer promised by the Torah." In the same chapter, in the part that censors cut from many printed editions, he names Yeshua directly and says He was executed by the court. Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Kings 11
From this and other rabbinic writings, the main objections are:
- He didn't do the Messiah's work. The temple wasn't rebuilt, the exiles weren't gathered, and the world isn't at peace Ezekiel 37:24-28; Isaiah 11:11-12; Isaiah 2:4.
- He was killed. A Messiah who dies has failed.
- The Messiah is a man, not God. "El is not a man" Numbers 23:19.
- The virgin birth. The Hebrew word in Isaiah 7:14 is almah, "young woman," not betulah, the usual word for virgin.
- His family line. Tribe and kingship pass through the father. If Joseph wasn't His father, the line doesn't count. And Matthew's line goes through King Jeconiah (also called Coniah), whose descendants God said would not sit on David's throne Jeremiah 22:30.
- Isaiah 53 is about Israel. Rashi, the great medieval commentator, read the suffering servant as the people of Israel. Rashi on Isaiah 52:13
What Scripture says
About the Messiah's work. Yes, Ezekiel 37, Isaiah 2 and Isaiah 11 are not fulfilled yet. We agree. But Scripture describes two comings: first to suffer, then to reign. "The Messiah, having been offered once to bear the sins of many, will appear a second time, apart from sin, to those who eagerly wait for Him, for salvation" Hebrews 9:28. Heaven must receive Him "until the times of restoration of all things" Acts 3:21. See Two comings: first the Lamb, then the King.
About His death. The prophets said the Messiah would die. "Messiah will be cut off and will have nothing" Daniel 9:26. The Servant "was cut off from the land of the living; for the transgression of My people He was stricken" Isaiah 53:8. And the same chapter says He would live again: "He shall prolong His days" Isaiah 53:10; Psalm 16:10. His death isn't a sign that He failed. It is what was written.
About who He is. The prophets gave the Messiah names no ordinary man could carry:
- "Mighty El, Everlasting Father" Isaiah 9:6. Isaiah uses the same title, "the Mighty El," for God Himself in the next chapter Isaiah 10:21.
- The righteous Branch of David will be called "Yahweh Our Righteousness" Jeremiah 23:5-6.
- Yahweh Himself says, "they will look on Me whom they pierced" Zechariah 12:10.
- David calls the Messiah "my Lord" Psalm 110:1; Matthew 22:41-46.
- One "like a son of man" comes with the clouds of heaven and receives a kingdom that will never pass away Daniel 7:13-14.
- His "goings forth are from of old, from the days of eternity" Micah 5:2.
About almah. It's true that almah means a young woman of marriageable age. But in the Hebrew Scriptures it is never clearly used of a married woman: it describes Rebekah before her marriage Genesis 24:43 and Moses' sister Miriam as a girl Exodus 2:8. About two centuries before Yeshua, the Jewish translators of the Greek Scriptures (the Septuagint) rendered it parthenos, "virgin," and Matthew quotes that translation Matthew 1:23.
About Jeconiah. God said to him, "though Coniah… were a signet ring on My right hand, yet I would pull you off from there" Jeremiah 22:24. But after the exile God said to Zerubbabel, Jeconiah's grandson 1 Chronicles 3:17-19: "I will take you… and will make you like a signet ring; for I have chosen you" Haggai 2:23. The same picture, reversed. Rabbinic writings themselves say the decree against Jeconiah was lifted: one says his exile atoned for him Talmud, Sanhedrin 37b–38a, and another that he repented in prison Leviticus Rabbah 19:6. Also, Luke's line comes through Nathan, not through Jeconiah at all Luke 3:31.
About Isaiah 53. Reading the servant as Israel is one Jewish reading, but not the only one. An ancient Aramaic paraphrase read in synagogues, Targum Jonathan, begins the passage, "Behold, My servant the Messiah shall prosper" (though it then gives the suffering to others) Targum Jonathan on Isaiah 52:13. And one opinion in the Talmud calls the Messiah "the leper of the house of Rabbi" (of the house of study), quoting "Surely He has borne our sicknesses" Isaiah 53:4 Talmud, Sanhedrin 98b. Within the passage itself, the servant suffers "for the transgression of My people" Isaiah 53:8. If the servant were the people, who would "My people" be?
A fair conclusion
These are real objections, held by people who take Scripture seriously. The answers above don't depend on later Christian tradition. They come from the Torah and the Prophets, the same Scriptures Yeshua and the apostles used to show who He is Luke 24:27; Acts 17:2-3.
Related studies
- Two comings: first the Lamb, then the King: The prophets describe a Messiah who suffers and a Messiah who reigns. Scripture shows one Messiah who comes twice.
- What Yeshua fulfilled at His first coming: His family line, His birthplace, the time He came, how He suffered and how He rose all match what the prophets wrote centuries before.
- Going too far: when rabbinic Judaism leads away from the Messiah: The Torah points to Yeshua. But some believers who go looking for answers in rabbinic Judaism end up rejecting Him. The danger isn't the Torah; it's the teaching that rejects the Messiah.