Loading the studies…

Protestant Christianity: beliefs, practices and traditions in the light of Scripture

Protestant churches gave millions the Bible and the message of grace. Measured by their own rule, Scripture alone, what do they teach that Scripture does not? An honest inventory, point by point.

As we saw in Martin Luther and the Reformation: the good, the bad and the ugly, the Reformation began as a call to go back to Scripture. Lutherans, Reformed, Anglicans, Baptists, Methodists, Pentecostals and many independent churches trace their faith to it. Many of us first came to Yeshua in those churches, and we write this with gratitude. We are examining teachings, not attacking people.

What Protestant churches hold that Scripture supports

  • Scripture as the final authority. The Westminster Confession (1646) says the whole counsel of God is in Scripture, "unto which nothing at any time is to be added, whether by new revelations of the Spirit, or traditions of men" (1.6) Westminster Confession of Faith (1646). That is the right rule Deuteronomy 4:2.
  • Salvation by grace through faith in Yeshua, not bought by works Ephesians 2:8-9.
  • Yeshua Himself: His deity, His atoning death and His bodily resurrection, confessed by most Protestant churches.
  • The Bible in the people's hands, in thousands of languages, along with prayer, missions and countless works of mercy.
  • Good works as fruit, not as price. The Heidelberg Catechism (1563) defines good works as "only those which are done out of true faith, conform to God's law, and are done for God's glory; and not those based on our own opinion or human tradition" (Q&A 91) Heidelberg Catechism (1563), Q&A 91.

This lesson simply applies the Protestant rule to Protestant teaching.

A word about diversity. "Protestant" is a large family whose branches differ, and the confessions are often more careful than many pulpits. So we quote the confessions in their own words, and say so when a point is mainly popular teaching. Not every Protestant believes every point.

Start with an inventory

If you are a Protestant Christian, start by making an honest inventory: what have you been taught, or what have you been teaching? Write it down. Then go through it point by point with the Scriptures open, like the Bereans, who "searched the Scriptures daily to find out whether these things were so" Acts 17:11. Trust no man, including us. "Test all things; hold fast what is good" 1 Thessalonians 5:21.

1. "The Law was nailed to the cross"

What is taught. Many sermons say the Torah ended at the cross, because "you are not under law but under grace" Romans 6:14. The classic confessions are more careful: they divide the Torah into three parts. The Westminster Confession says the ceremonial laws "are now abrogated, under the New Testament" (19.3), the judicial laws "expired together with the State of that people" (19.4), but "the moral law doth for ever bind all" (19.5) Westminster Confession of Faith (1646).

What Scripture says. Yeshua said: "Do not think that I came to destroy the Torah or the Prophets. I did not come to destroy but to fulfill" Matthew 5:17. Paul asked: "Do we then make void the Torah through faith? Certainly not! On the contrary, we establish the Torah" Romans 3:31. What was nailed to the cross was "the handwritten record of debt that was against us with its decrees" Colossians 2:14, not God's instructions. And Scripture doesn't sort the commandments into a "moral" part that stays and a "ceremonial" part that ended. Some apply only to certain people and some need a temple, but that is another question Which commandments apply today?.

Go deeper: Colossians 2:14: what was nailed to the cross?, "Not under law but under grace", "Fulfill" the Torah does not mean "finish" it, Why some things can't be done now.

2. Sunday as "the Christian Sabbath"

What is taught. The Westminster Confession says the Sabbath "from the resurrection of Christ, was changed into the first day of the week, which, in Scripture, is called the Lord's day, and is to be continued to the end of the world, as the Christian Sabbath" (21.7) Westminster Confession of Faith (1646). The Lutheran Augsburg Confession (1530) puts it differently: "Scripture has abrogated the Sabbath-day," and, since a day was needed, "it appears that the Church designated the Lord's Day for this purpose" (art. 28) Augsburg Confession (1530), article 28.

What Scripture says. God blessed the seventh day and made it holy Genesis 2:2-3, and wrote "Remember" in the Ten Commandments Exodus 20:8-11. Yeshua went to the synagogue on Shabbat "as His custom was" Luke 4:16. Paul did the same Acts 17:2; Acts 13:42-44. "So then, there remains a Shabbat rest for the people of Elohim" Hebrews 4:9. No verse records a change of day, and "the Lord's day" of Revelation 1:10 is never identified with Sunday. Scripture alone doesn't get us to Sunday. Not all Protestants keep Sunday: Seventh Day Baptists (since the 1600s) and Seventh-day Adventists keep the seventh day.

Go deeper: Shabbat, What the "first day" verses really say, From Shabbat to Sunday: who made the change.

3. Christmas and Easter

What is taught. Most churches make them the high points of the year, yet some early Protestants objected. The Directory for the Public Worship of God (1645), prepared by the Westminster Assembly, says: "There is no day commanded in scripture to be kept holy under the gospel but the Lord's day," and "Festival days, vulgarly called Holy-days, having no warrant in the word of God, are not to be continued" Westminster Directory for Public Worship (1645).

What Scripture says. They were right that these days have no warrant in Scripture. But God did give appointed times of His own: "The appointed times of Yahweh, which you shall proclaim as holy convocations, these are My appointed times" Leviticus 23:2. They point to the Messiah, and they were never canceled.

Go deeper: Where December 25 came from, From Pesach (Passover) to Easter: the date was changed, God's appointed times (the Feasts), How the appointed times were replaced: a timeline.

4. "All foods are clean now"

What is taught. The food instructions are usually counted among the ceremonial laws that ended (Westminster 19.3). Many modern versions read part of Mark 7:19 as the writer's comment: "Thus He declared all foods clean."

What Scripture says. Mark 7 is about eating with unwashed hands Mark 7:2-5, not about which animals are food; the Greek can simply say the food goes "out into the latrine, purging all the foods" Mark 7:19. Years after the resurrection Peter could still say, "I have never eaten anything common or unclean" Acts 10:14, and he explained his vision himself: "Elohim has shown me that I should not call any man common or unclean" Acts 10:28.

Go deeper: Clean and unclean foods, Mark 7: unwashed hands, not unclean animals, Peter's vision: about people, not pork, Romans 14 and 1 Timothy 4 in context.

5. Israel and the Church

What is taught. Dispensational theology, widely held in evangelical churches, was set out by John Nelson Darby in the 1830s John Nelson Darby and dispensationalism (Christian Today) and spread through the Scofield Reference Bible of 1909 Scofield Reference Bible, first edition (1909). One of its best-known teachers, Charles Ryrie, wrote: "A dispensationalist keeps Israel and the church distinct" Charles Ryrie, Dispensationalism, p. 39. Many in other traditions go the opposite way and teach that the Church has replaced Israel.

What Scripture says. Neither two peoples with two plans, nor replacement. There is one olive tree; believers from the nations are grafted in among its branches: "do not boast against the branches… you do not support the root, but the root supports you" Romans 11:17-18. They were "alienated from the citizenship of Israel," and now "have been brought near by the blood of the Messiah" Ephesians 2:12-13. The pre-tribulation rapture usually goes with this system; sincere believers differ on its timing, and we weigh the views later, in The gathering of believers (the "rapture").

Go deeper: The Two Houses of Israel, The New Covenant is made with both houses, Believers from the nations become Israel, Not Gentiles anymore: part of Israel through Yeshua.

6. "Going to heaven when you die"

What is taught. Many sermons and songs make heaven the goal of the Christian life. The confessions look further: Westminster says the souls of the righteous are received into heaven, "waiting for the full redemption of their bodies" (32.1) Westminster Confession of Faith (1646).

What Scripture says. The hope is the resurrection: "the dead in the Messiah will rise first" 1 Thessalonians 4:16-17. The meek "will inherit the earth" Matthew 5:5, the redeemed "will reign on the earth" Revelation 5:10, and the New Jerusalem comes down, for "the tabernacle of Elohim is with men" Revelation 21:1-3. What happens between death and the resurrection isn't fully revealed.

Go deeper: Do we go to heaven when we die?.

7. The "sinner's prayer"

What is taught. Many tracts close with a suggested prayer. The Billy Graham Evangelistic Association's "Steps to Peace with God" offers one that begins, "Dear Lord Jesus, I know that I am a sinner, and I ask for Your forgiveness," and then says, "If you prayed this prayer, the Bible says:" with Romans 10:13 Billy Graham Evangelistic Association, "Steps to Peace with God".

What Scripture says. Calling on the Lord, confessing sin and trusting Yeshua are right, and many people sincerely came to faith praying words like these. But Scripture never shows an apostle leading anyone in a set prayer. They said: "Repent therefore and turn back, so that your sins may be blotted out" Acts 3:19. Yeshua warned: "Not everyone who says to Me, 'Lord, Lord,' will enter the kingdom of heaven, but the one who does the will of My Father who is in heaven" Matthew 7:21. Assurance rests on Yeshua, and it shows in a changed life 1 John 2:3-4, not in a moment we remember.

Go deeper: The way home: Yeshua, One gospel: what Yeshua and the apostles preached.

8. "Once saved, always saved"

What is taught. Here Protestants differ. The Westminster Confession says those God has accepted "can neither totally nor finally fall away from the state of grace, but shall certainly persevere therein to the end" (17.1) Westminster Confession of Faith (1646), and the Baptist Faith and Message says, "All true believers endure to the end" (art. V) Baptist Faith and Message 2000. Methodists and many Pentecostals teach that a believer can fall away. The popular version, that a decision once made saves no matter how a person lives afterward, is taught by neither side's confessions.

What Scripture says. The promise is for those who follow: "My sheep hear My voice, and I know them, and they follow Me" John 10:27. Without settling the Calvinist and Arminian debate, Scripture is clear that faith that never obeys is not the faith that saves James 2:17-24.

Go deeper: Grace and obedience, The fine was paid, but the law still stands, "Fallen from grace".

9. Clergy and laity, and church as a business

What is taught. This is more practice than doctrine. The Reformation taught the priesthood of all believers, yet in many churches one paid professional does nearly all the teaching while everyone else watches. Some are run much like businesses, with tithe sermons from Malachi 3:10. Many pastors, it must be said, serve sacrificially and for little pay.

What Scripture says. All believers are "a royal priesthood, a holy nation" 1 Peter 2:9. When the assembly met, "each of you has a psalm, has a teaching" 1 Corinthians 14:26. Paul defended support for those who teach 1 Corinthians 9:14, yet he worked with his own hands so as not to be a burden Acts 20:33-35. Elders are to shepherd the flock "not for dishonest gain but eagerly" 1 Peter 5:2.

Go deeper: Malachi 3:10 and the tithe: what the Torah describes, Who God appointed to teach His Torah.

10. So many denominations

What is taught. Each denomination teaches its distinctives as what the Bible says. The Center for the Study of Global Christianity estimates about 47300 Christian denominations worldwide (mid-2023) Number of Christian denominations (estimate, 2023). That estimate covers all of Christianity, not only Protestants, and is a sum of country-by-country counts, so one body present in many countries is counted many times Pew Research Center, Global Christianity (2011), appendix B. The number of truly distinct traditions is far smaller. Still, the divisions are real.

What Scripture says. "That you all speak the same thing, and that there be no divisions among you" 1 Corinthians 1:10. Yeshua prayed "that they all may be one" John 17:21. Not every difference is sin, but when one Bible yields so many systems, it is the systems that need correcting.

Go deeper: One Bible, three systems, different answers.

Measured by its own rule

Protestants were right to say "Scripture alone." But Sunday as the Sabbath and the church holidays came from church tradition, as Augsburg and the Westminster Directory partly admit. Luther brought back grace, but not the Torah Martin Luther and the Reformation: the good, the bad and the ugly. Finishing what the Reformation started means applying its own rule all the way.

Coming home

None of this is said against the sincere believers in Protestant churches, or the pastors who serve them. Most of us were taught these things too. What matters is not where we started, but whether we keep following the Scriptures when they lead somewhere new.

So test everything, including us 1 Thessalonians 5:21. Keep your inventory open, with your Bible open next to it; later, in Are you sure? Examine what you believe, we come back to how. Nobody comes home all at once. We come home one step at a time Coming home one step at a time.

Related studies

Open in the study app