Loading the studies…

One Bible, three systems, different answers

Rabbinic Judaism, the Catholic Church and the Protestant churches all appeal to the Bible, yet they contradict each other on essential points. That tells us something.

Three large religious systems base their teaching on the Bible: rabbinic Judaism, the Catholic Church, and the Protestant and evangelical churches. If each one simply built its beliefs on Scripture, we would expect them to agree on the essentials. Instead, they contradict each other in critical areas.

Where they disagree

  • The Messiah. Rabbinic Judaism rejects Yeshua as the Messiah Maimonides, Mishneh Torah, Kings 11. Catholics and Protestants accept Him.
  • The final authority. Rabbinic Judaism places the "Oral Torah," written down in the Mishnah and the Talmud, alongside the written Torah The "Oral Torah" and the writings that came from it. The Catholic Church places Sacred Tradition and the Church's teaching office alongside Scripture. Protestant churches say "Scripture alone," yet most kept Sunday, Christmas and Easter, which took shape in church tradition rather than in a command of Scripture How the appointed times were replaced: a timeline.
  • Shabbat. Rabbinic Judaism keeps the seventh day. The Catholic Church teaches that Sunday took its place Catechism of the Catholic Church 2175. Most Protestant churches keep Sunday too, and many call it the "Christian Sabbath."
  • The Torah. Rabbinic Judaism keeps it, with many rabbinic rules added After the prophets: fences and traditions. Most churches teach that its ceremonial laws ended at the cross, though many say its moral law, the Ten Commandments, still applies.

What that tells us

"Elohim is not of confusion but of peace" 1 Corinthians 14:33. Scripture doesn't contradict itself, so where systems contradict each other on essentials, at least one of them, and maybe all of them, is following something other than Scripture. Yeshua said it of the leaders of His day: "In vain they worship Me, teaching as doctrines the commandments of men. For laying aside the commandment of Elohim, you hold fast the tradition of men" Mark 7:7-8.

Notice the pattern. Each system started with Scripture and then added an authority that ended up explaining Scripture for it: the rabbis' tradition, the Church's tradition, or a denomination's doctrine. Once that happens, the Bible is read to fit the system, instead of the system being corrected by the Bible.

What each one kept, and what each one lost

Said fairly, each holds something true. Judaism kept Shabbat, the feasts and the Torah, but rabbinic Judaism does not accept Yeshua as the Messiah. The churches received the Messiah, but set aside much of the Torah He kept. Revelation describes God's people at the end as "those who keep the commandments of Elohim and the faith of Yeshua" Revelation 14:12: both together. See Torah and Messiah: two halves that belong together.

Not against people

This isn't about people. There are sincere, God-fearing people in all three, Jewish and Christian alike, and many of them have never been shown these things. It's about authority: whose word has the last word. The same test applies to us: "Test all things; hold fast what is good" 1 Thessalonians 5:21. "To the Torah and to the testimony! If they do not speak according to this word, it is because there is no dawn for them" Isaiah 8:20.

Related studies

Open in the study app