Loading the studies…
Handles on the heart: how religion and politics have used human emotions
God gave us feelings, and people who want to control others learn to grab them like handles. How it has been done from Babel to today, how to recognize it, and why it includes us.
A suitcase has a handle so that anyone can pick it up and carry it wherever he wants. The human heart has handles too. None of them is evil in itself. God made us with feelings: Yeshua was angry at hard hearts Mark 3:5, and He was moved with compassion for the crowds, "like sheep having no shepherd" Matthew 9:36. But anyone who wants to control people, from a pulpit or from a platform, sooner or later learns where the handles are, and how to pull them.
The handles
- Fear: of punishment, of loss, of the enemy, of the future.
- Guilt: "you haven't done enough."
- The need to belong: no one wants to be left outside.
- Pride: "we are the ones who see."
- The desire for certainty: a clear answer feels safer than an honest "we don't know."
- Hope: for healing, money, rescue, a better tomorrow.
- Anger: at an injustice, real or imagined, and at the people blamed for it.
- Trust in authority: "he's the pastor, the rabbi, the expert, the leader; he must know."
The question is never whether we feel these things. It's who is holding the handle, and where he is carrying us.
Scripture shows it
- Babel: pride and unity. "Come, let us build ourselves a city and a tower whose top is in the heavens, and let us make a name for ourselves, lest we be scattered over the face of the whole earth" Genesis 11:4. Pride and fear held a people together against God's command to fill the earth Genesis 9:1.
- The golden calf: impatience and fear. "When the people saw that Moses delayed to come down from the mountain," they said to Aaron, "Up, make us gods who shall go before us" Exodus 32:1. Aaron gave the crowd what it wanted, and then called it "a feast to Yahweh" Exodus 32:5.
- Saul: the fear of people. "I have sinned, for I have transgressed the command of Yahweh and your words, because I feared the people and obeyed their voice" 1 Samuel 15:24. The king was carried by the handle he was supposed to resist.
- Jeroboam: the fear of losing power. Afraid the kingdom would return to the house of David if the people kept going up to worship in Jerusalem, he made two calves of gold and said, "It is too much for you to go up to Jerusalem" 1 Kings 12:26-28. Fear for his throne was dressed up as concern for the people.
- The council: fear for the nation. "If we let Him alone like this, everyone will believe in Him, and the Romans will come and take away both our place and nation" John 11:48.
- The crowd. "The chief priests stirred up the crowd, so that he would rather release Barabbas to them" Mark 15:11.
Through history
The same handles have been pulled ever since. A few examples, told as fairly as we can:
- Indulgences: fear and guilt. In the early 1500s, indulgences were preached as relief from punishment in purgatory, even for loved ones who had died. A rhyme traditionally attributed to the preacher Johann Tetzel ran something like "as soon as the coin in the coffer rings, the soul from purgatory springs." We saw Luther's answer in Martin Luther and the Reformation: the good, the bad and the ugly. To be fair, the Council of Trent later ordered "all evil gains" for obtaining indulgences to be abolished Council of Trent, Decree on Indulgences (1563).
- The Crusades: hope and fear. At Clermont in 1095, Pope Urban II called Christians to an armed expedition to the East. The accounts of his speech differ, but in Fulcher of Chartres' account he promised that "all who die by the way, whether by land or by sea, or in battle against the pagans, shall have immediate remission of sins" Urban II at Clermont (1095), the accounts. Forgiveness, which comes through the Messiah's blood Ephesians 1:7, was tied to going to war.
- A faith that unites an empire: belonging and authority. Constantine favored the church, made Sunday a civil day of rest in 321 (see From Shabbat to Sunday: who made the change), and after Nicaea urged all the churches to keep Easter on one day, apart from the Jewish reckoning Eusebius, Life of Constantine 3.18. Historians debate how sincere his faith was; a united church clearly served a united empire.
- Setting dates: certainty and hope. William Miller taught that Yeshua would return by 1843-1844. When that date passed, Miller openly admitted his error; then a new date was set, October 22, 1844. Many sincere believers were left in what became known as the "Great Disappointment" The Great Disappointment (1844). Dates have been set and re-set many times since. Yeshua said: "Of that day and hour no one knows" Matthew 24:36.
- Prosperity preaching: hope and greed. The size of the gift tied to the size of the blessing, as we saw in Itching ears: feel-good and prosperity sermons. Peter warned: "By covetousness they will exploit you with deceptive words" 2 Peter 2:3.
- Outrage: anger and belonging. Every side of politics has used it, and today it can be measured. A 2017 study of more than 560000 Twitter messages about gun control, same-sex marriage and climate change found that each added moral-emotional word raised a message's spread by about 20%, and more within like-minded networks than between them Brady et al., moral emotion and how messages spread (2017). Outrage spreads fast, especially inside our own camp.
This isn't only about "them." Religious movements like ours can pull the same handles: fear ("if you don't keep the right calendar, you're lost"), pride ("only we have the truth"), teachings sold to insiders, dates for the end. A message can be right about the Torah and still be delivered by pulling on people's emotions.
How to recognize manipulation
These signs apply to a sermon, a campaign speech, a video or a post:
- Urgency: "decide now," "before it's too late," "give today."
- An emotion first, then a request: fear, guilt or anger, followed by a request for money, a vote or loyalty.
- Us against them: the world is divided into the good people (us) and the enemy (them).
- Flattery: "only we see the truth"; "you're not like the sheep out there."
- A leader who can't be questioned. The Bereans checked even the apostle Paul against the Scriptures Acts 17:11.
- Questions punished: whoever asks is called rebellious, divisive or a traitor.
- Isolation: you're told not to listen to outsiders, your family or other sources.
- Secret knowledge for insiders, or for pay. Yeshua said: "I spoke openly to the world… and in secret I have said nothing" John 18:20.
- Moving goalposts: the prediction fails, it is re-dated, and the demand stays the same (we will look at this later, in What was a prophet's job?).
- Follow the money: who benefits? Money, power, attention, a following.
One sign by itself doesn't prove anything. Several together are a warning.
What to do instead
- Pause. A strong emotion is a signal to slow down, not to speed up.
- Open the Scriptures and read the verses in their context (see Keys for reading the Scriptures accurately).
- Hear the other side from the people who hold it, not only from their opponents: "The first one to plead his cause seems right, until his neighbor comes and examines him" Proverbs 18:17.
- Ask who benefits, pray, and talk it over with someone outside the group.
- Test the spirits, "whether they are of Elohim; because many false prophets have gone out into the world" 1 John 4:1.
Scripture also takes the handles out of other people's hands:
- Fear: "The fear of man brings a snare, but whoever trusts in Yahweh will be kept safe" Proverbs 29:25. "For Elohim has not given us a spirit of fear, but of power and of love and of a sound mind" 2 Timothy 1:7.
- The need for approval: "If I still pleased men, I would not be a servant of the Messiah" Galatians 1:10.
- Guilt: forgiveness isn't for sale. "There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in the Messiah Yeshua" Romans 8:1.
- Political hope and anger: Yeshua said, "My kingdom is not of this world" John 18:36, and "Render therefore to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to Elohim the things that are Elohim's" Matthew 22:21. A believer can vote, serve and care about his country, but no party, nation or candidate is the kingdom of God, and none of them owns our conscience.
This includes us
Everything in this lesson applies to this website too. Don't let us persuade you one way or the other. Trust no man, including us: "Thus says Yahweh: 'Cursed is the man who trusts in man and makes flesh his strength, whose heart departs from Yahweh'" Jeremiah 17:5. Trust the Scriptures, and ask God for wisdom; He "gives to all generously and without reproach" James 1:5.
Take what we share here, take whatever you believe today, and lay both side by side with the Scriptures, as the Bereans did when they "searched the Scriptures daily to find out whether these things were so" Acts 17:11. Don't fall for anything but what Scripture says.
And when the evidence points one way, act on it. Yeshua said: "If anyone wants to do His will, he will know concerning the teaching, whether it is from Elohim or whether I speak on My own" John 7:17. "Be doers of the word, and not hearers only" James 1:22. The Father isn't grabbing your heart to carry you off somewhere you don't want to go. He is calling you home, one step at a time, with His word open in front of you.
Related studies
- Pride, agendas and the courage to say "we were wrong": Often the biggest obstacle to the truth isn't the evidence but pride, position and agendas. Scripture shows what that costs, and what God does for those who humble themselves.
- Are you sure? Examine what you believe: All of us tend to defend what we already believe without checking it. Scripture tells us to examine it, starting with ourselves.
- Itching ears: feel-good and prosperity sermons: Paul warned of teachers who tell people what they want to hear. The message Yeshua and the apostles preached included repentance, the cross and sometimes rejection.
- What was a prophet's job?: God's prophets called His people back from sin, and many were rejected for it. The popular ones were usually the false prophets.
- Martin Luther and the Reformation: the good, the bad and the ugly: Luther called the church back to Scripture and to grace through faith. He stopped short of the Torah, and late in life he wrote terrible things about the Jews. An honest look, and a lesson for all of us.
- From Shabbat to Sunday: who made the change: No verse moves Shabbat. The change came through a Roman emperor's law and church councils centuries later.