Loading the studies…

How the drift happened (AD 70–375)

It didn't happen in one day, and it didn't come from Yeshua or the apostles. Persecution, the wish not to look Jewish, new teachings and finally imperial laws pulled believers away, step by step.

The change didn't come from Yeshua or the apostles, and it didn't happen all at once. Here are the steps, each with its source, so you can check them yourself.

  • AD 70: Rome destroys the temple. Emperor Vespasian then orders every Jew, wherever he lives, to pay two drachmas a year to the Capitol in Rome, the tax they used to pay to the temple in Jerusalem Josephus, Jewish War 7.218. Under Domitian (AD 81–96) the tax is collected "with the utmost rigour," even from people who lived as Jews without saying so publicly Suetonius, Domitian 12. Living as a Jew now cost money and could bring trouble.
  • About AD 110: Ignatius of Antioch (some scholars date the letter later) praises those who are "no longer observing the Sabbath, but living in the observance of the Lord's Day" Ignatius, To the Magnesians 9. Scholars debate the exact Greek, but the direction is clear: Shabbat is being set against something new.
  • AD 132–135: The second revolt against Rome. A late Roman source says the Jews rose up because they had been forbidden to circumcise Historia Augusta, Hadrian 14.2, and later Jewish tradition remembers that after the war there was a persecution against circumcision, Torah study and Shabbat; historians debate how far those decrees went. After the revolt Jews are banned from Jerusalem, and the city is renamed Aelia (Aelia Capitolina), after the emperor Hadrian. According to Eusebius, until then all fifteen leaders of the believers in Jerusalem had been Hebrews; from then on the church there is made up of Gentiles, and its first Gentile leader is Marcus Eusebius, Church History 4.5–4.6. Looking Jewish had become dangerous.
  • About AD 155–160: Justin Martyr teaches that Shabbat and other commandments were given to Israel because of their hardness of heart Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 18–23. Yet he admits that some believers in Yeshua still keep the Torah, says they will be saved if they don't try to persuade others to do the same, and mentions Christians who won't even associate with them or welcome them into their homes, though Justin himself says, "I do not agree with them" Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 47.
  • About AD 190: Pesach (Passover). The believers of Asia, led by Polycrates of Ephesus, still keep Pesach (Passover) on the 14th day of the first month of the biblical calendar, following Philip, the apostle John, Polycarp and others: "We observe the exact day; neither adding, nor taking away." Victor, bishop of Rome, tries to cut off all the churches of Asia, and even Irenaeus rebukes him Eusebius, Church History 5.24.
  • AD 321–363: Laws and councils. Constantine orders city dwellers to rest on "the venerable day of the Sun" (321); in 325 Nicaea replaces the date of Pesach (Passover); Laodicea forbids resting on Shabbat (about 363). See What was there in the beginning is still there at the end for the sources.
  • About AD 375: The Nazarenes. Epiphanius describes believers in Yeshua who are "still fettered by the Law—circumcision, the Sabbath, and the rest," and lists them among the heretics Epiphanius, Panarion 29. More than 300 years after the resurrection, some still kept the Torah while believing in Yeshua, and they were called heretics for it.

Why it happened

  • Persecution and money. After AD 70, and again after AD 135, keeping Shabbat and the feasts made a person look Jewish, and being Jewish meant a special tax and suspicion.
  • Wanting to look different. Many leaders began to present their faith as something new and separate from the Jews. After Nicaea, Constantine's letter to the churches said, "Let us then have nothing in common with the detestable Jewish crowd" Eusebius, Life of Constantine 3.18.
  • Teachers without the Torah. As the church grew mostly among the nations, and even in Jerusalem the leadership passed to Gentiles after AD 135, most church leaders hadn't grown up with the Torah. New explanations replaced what the apostles taught.
  • Then the law. Once the emperor and the councils made the change official, what began as a custom became the rule.

The same pattern again

This is the pattern from Moses to Yeshua repeating: a drift, little by little, toward the customs of the nations. Paul had warned the elders of Ephesus that "from among yourselves men will rise up, speaking perverse things, to draw away the disciples after themselves" Acts 20:29-30. But it was never everyone. From the women at the tomb to the Nazarenes of the fourth century, there were always some who kept what the apostles kept, and today many are returning to it Jude 1:3.

But what about…?

Some passages are often read as if the change came from Scripture itself. Each has its own study:

Related studies

Open in the study app